Imagine it is past midnight in Lagos. The generator has gone off, the house is finally quiet, and a young woman lying in the dark types a question she has not been able to ask anyone she knows.
"Am I wrong to want to leave this job when my family depends on me?"
The answer arrives in seconds. It is warm. It is thoughtful. It tells her that her feelings are valid, that her well-being matters, that she deserves a life that feels like her own.
She feels lighter. She puts the phone face down on the pillow.
Nobody will ever know she asked.
That last sentence is the one worth thinking about.
A Quiet Migration
Something has shifted in where people take their troubles. A study published in JAMA Pediatrics earlier this year found that nearly one in five young people surveyed had turned to AI chatbots for advice when they were struggling, and most of those users said the advice was helpful.
I do not want to begin by condemning this. Many of those people were helped. Some of them had nobody else to ask. Some had asked people before and been mocked, gossiped about, or preached at. A chatbot does not tell your mother. It does not bring up your confession in an argument three years later. It does not look at you differently at the next family meeting.
That is precisely why it deserves a careful look. When a whole generation begins moving its most private conversations into one room, the question is not only whether the room is helpful. The question is what kind of room it is, and what it is quietly building in us.
The Room Without Witnesses
Every room is designed around what it must hold. A bedroom is built for privacy. A living room is built for gathering. A courtyard is built for being seen. Change the room, and you change what happens inside it.
For generations, the rooms where we brought our troubles had witnesses in them. In many Nigerian homes, that witness was an elder, an aunty, a pastor or an imam, a friend from secondary school who knew you before you learnt to perform. Those rooms were not always safe. Sometimes the aunty had told the whole extended family by Sunday. Sometimes the counsel came wrapped in judgement, or in that heavy question, "What will people say?" Many of us learnt early that confiding was risky, and that the safest secret was the one you told nobody.
So it makes sense that when a room without witnesses appeared, people walked straight in.
But a witness is not only a risk. A witness is also a weight. The person who hears your confession carries something away with them. They remember. They will see you next week. They will notice whether you did what you said you would do. Their counsel has weight precisely because they have something at stake in your life.
A chatbot has nothing at stake. It cannot be disappointed in you. It will not be hurt if you ignore its advice, and it will not be proud of you if you take it. Tomorrow it will greet you as warmly as if yesterday never happened.
We call that safety. Sometimes it is. But it is also the absence of something we need.
Why Agreement Feels Like Support
There is another feature of this room worth naming. It leans towards agreeing with you.
This is not a conspiracy theory. In April 2025, OpenAI rolled back an update to ChatGPT after widespread complaints that it had become excessively flattering. The tools have changed since then, but the pull has not disappeared. A product people enjoy is a product that makes them feel understood, and the quickest way to make someone feel understood is to tell them they are right.
Now think about how we phrase our questions at midnight. We rarely type, "Here is the full story, including the parts where I behaved badly." We type the version of the story we can live with. And the machine, which only has our version, responds to our version.
The young woman asked whether she was wrong to want to leave. Suppose she did not mention that she has left three jobs in two years, each time at the point where things became difficult. She may not have noticed that pattern herself. The machine certainly could not.
A friend who has known her since university would have noticed. And that friend might have said something uncomfortable: "Are you leaving the job, or are you leaving the difficulty again?"
That sentence would have stung. It might also have been the most useful thing anyone said to her all year.
Resistance Is Load-Bearing
Anyone who understands how buildings stand learns a simple truth: support is a form of resistance. A column holds up a roof because it pushes back against the weight. A wall carries load because it refuses to give way. If you lean on a wall and it bends to your shape, it is not supporting you. It is falling with you.
Human relationships work in much the same way. The people who truly held us up were rarely the ones who agreed with everything. They were the ones who pushed back at the right moment, with love. The friend who said, "No. You are better than this." The parent who refused to bless a bad decision. The colleague who read your proposal and said, gently, "This is not ready yet."
We do not always thank these people at the time. But they become part of the structure of who we are.
A confidant who can never be disappointed in you cannot give you this. Not because it is wicked, but because it has nothing to resist with. It has no history with you, no stake in your future, no relationship that your choices could damage. It can describe courage. It cannot lend you any.
The Question Beneath the Habit
It would be easy to end here with a neat instruction: talk to real people instead. But that would ignore why so many people stopped talking to real people in the first place.
If you find yourself telling a machine what you cannot tell anyone you know, the honest question is not "Is AI bad?" It is something closer to home.
What happened to the rooms in my life where I could be honest?
Did they never exist, or did I close them?
Who in my life has earned the right to disagree with me?
And who have I quietly stopped telling the whole story?
For some, the answer is painful. Perhaps you were betrayed by someone you trusted, and the lesson you took away was "never again". That lesson made sense at the time. But a lesson learnt in pain is not automatically a lesson worth keeping for life. You can respect why you built the wall without agreeing to live behind it forever.
For others, the answer is simpler. You have people. You just stopped calling them, because typing into a box at midnight is easier than being seen.
Using the Room Well
None of this means the tool has no place. Used well, it can be a useful drafting room: somewhere to untangle your thoughts before you speak them, to rehearse a hard conversation, or to find words for something you have never had words for. The trouble begins when the drafting room becomes the only room in the house.
A few ways to keep it in its place:
- Tell it the unflattering version. Include the parts of the story where you were wrong, then ask directly, "Where could I be the problem?"
- Ask for the case against you. Before you accept an answer that feels comforting, ask for the strongest argument against what you want to do.
- Use it to prepare, not to conclude. Let it help you find the words, then take those words to a person.
- Notice the secrecy. If the main appeal is that nobody will ever know, pay attention. Secrecy can protect us. It can also protect a pattern.
- Know its limits. If you are in real distress, a chatbot is not a substitute for a qualified counsellor, a doctor, or a trusted person who can sit with you. Please reach out to one.
A Reflection for This Week
Take a sheet of paper and draw three columns.
In the first, write the last three personal questions you asked a machine.
In the second, beside each one, write the name of a person who could have heard that question instead.
In the third, write honestly why you did not ask them. Was it fear of judgement? Fear of gossip? Or fear of being told something true?
Then choose one of those questions and take it to that person this week. Not the whole burden. One honest conversation, with a witness.
Notice what it feels like to be heard by someone who could be disappointed in you, and chooses to stay.
The Witness We Need
Technology should serve our lives, not quietly rearrange them. A tool that is always available, always patient, and always on our side is a remarkable thing. But we were not built only to be comforted. We were built to be known.
And to be known, someone has to see the whole story, carry it with them, and still be there next week.
A machine can tell you that you are right. Only someone who can be disappointed in you can help you become better.




